[ Jocelyn Ireson-Paine's Home Page | Publications | Dobbs Code Talk Index | Dobbs Blog Version ]

Tipping the Spherical Cow

Everybody knows where to get coffee. But can anyone tell me where to get the subsequent beverages shown in Madeleine Ball's cartoon An autocatalytic cycle? Perhaps only in an alternate universe?

Madeleine's cartoons are listed here. Her site, Tipping the Spherical Cow, surely takes part of its name from an old scientific joke. I first read this in the book A Random Walk in Science, reviewed on Amazon; here is one version:

Worried by the ever-rising cost of animal feed, a dairy farmer hires three consultants — an operational researcher, a nutritionist, and a pure mathematician — to tell him how to increase his profits and continue to make a living. They spend a day looking around the farm, and then go off to write their reports.

Two weeks later, all three reports drop through the farmer's letterbox. He opens the operational researcher's report, and sees pages of meticulous diagrams showing how to optimise the layout of fodder crops for easy planting, and timetables for staggering breeding dates to even out milk production across the year. He opens the nutritionist's report: detailed lists of grass varieties, carefully sorted by seed price, rust-resistance, and usefulness as silage. He opens the physicist's report and reads the first paragraph. It begins "Consider a spherical cow".